An Inspector Calls Sheila And Mr Birling Essay

Comparison Of The Attitudes Of Arthur Birling And Sheila Birling From An Inspector Calls By J.B. Priestley

Comparison of The Attitudes Of Arthur Birling And Sheila Birling From An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley

An Inspector Calls by J.B Priestley was first performed in 1945. The
play was set in 1912 before the war; it centres on the wealthy Birling
family. A visit from the mysterious Inspector Goole, during the
celebration of Sheila Birling's and Gerald Croft's engagement, proves
to be a horrifying experience for them as they learn that they have
all played a part in the suicide of a young girl called Eva Smith.

From the start we see that Mr Birling is a hardheaded businessman and
seems to look out for only himself and his reputation. In his speech
to Gerald and Eric he tells them "a man has to make his own way-has to
look after himself -and his family, of course". Now this seems to show
his arrogance towards others. He is very proud and happy that his
daughter is marrying into a higher class and believes he will get more
respect.

Sheila Birling is presented at first as a childish playful girl. She
is not stupid and we know that she is very suspicious of Gerald's
absence last summer. When on hearing the news, of Eva Smiths death,
she is shocked. Through out the play Sheila seems aware of her
parent's ignorance and at one point she tries to stop her mother doing
some thing she will regret because she under stand s what the
inspector is doing

At the start during the dinner both of the characters are very happy
and are drinking and eating. They begin to have a conversation and Mr
Birling tells them that "just because the miners came out on strike,
there's a lot of wild talk about labour trouble in the near future."
And then he goes on to say that the war will not happen and that the
titanic will not sink. The irony in this is that we know he is wrong
even though he is saying that those who that there is going to be a
war are wrong. Priestly uses the dramatic irony of this to show how
misguided Birling is and what an irresponsible figure in society he
is. He then says that by 1940 there will be peace and prosperity and
rapid progress everywhere. Priestly was writing this play in 1934 he
knew and so did everyone else at the time that Mr Birling was wrong.
This shows us that what Birling was saying was a lie. It showed people
how ignorant Mr Birling was. This made you wonder if all of his
priorities were wrong.

When we are told the stories of how both characters were connected to
Eva Smith. We see although Sheila is caring she treated Eva smith no
better than her father did and that what they did to her was quite
similar. They both had her thrown out from her job. They both did it
for pathetic reasons. Neither of them thought about how the
consequences would affect Eva. Mr Birling threw Eva smith out of her
job at his Factory because she asked for a small pay rise of just
...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

Compare and Contrast the ways in which Priestley presents the attitudes of Birling and the Inspector throughout the play,

1924 words - 8 pages The play An Inspector Calls is set in 1912,"Edwardian England" but written and first performed in 1945. This is very significant because between these two dates humanity witnessed or encountered many times of great suffering such as World War 1, World War 2 and the sinking of the unsinkable Titanic, which gives the reader a sense of continuity, that events will happen...

Review of An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley

2925 words - 12 pages Review of An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley John Boynton Priestly was a socialist. He believed that whether we acknowledged it or not, we are in a community and have a responsibility to look after others. He wrote "An Inspector Calls" to ...

Analysis of An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley

2331 words - 9 pages Analysis of An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley ‘An Inspector Call’ is a play written by J.B. Priestly, which was set in 1912 but was first produced in 1945. The play opens with the Birling family and Gerald croft seated in the dining room and celebrating the engagement of Sheila and Gerald. The Birling is a middle class family and Mr. Birling is a prosperous manufacturer who is concerned in his own profit and has no...

The Role of the Inspector in an An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley

2488 words - 10 pages The Role of the Inspector in an An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley All three acts, which are continuous, take place in the dinning room of the Birlings' house in Brumley, an industrial city in the North Midlands. Mr Birling his wife Mrs Birling and his son Eric are celebrating the engagement of his daughter Sheila and Gerald Croft. An Inspector calls round to question the family on the death a girl called Eva Smith...

Ideas of Community in An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley

3918 words - 16 pages Ideas of Community in An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley "We don't live alone. We are members of one body. We are responsible for each other. And I tell you that a time will soon come when if men will not learn that lesson then they will be taught it in fire and blood and anguish" Inspector's Final speech. An Inspector Calls is as its name implies- a detective play with a twist. Written by John Boynton...

How does J.B. Priestley use the character of Mr Arthur Birling to criticise aspects of early twentieth society?

1307 words - 5 pages 'An Inspector Calls' is a play by J.B. Priestley which criticises the social structure of the early twentieth century society.J.B. Priestley was born at the end of the 19th century; in 1894. At this time, Britain and Europe had a very class conscious society. Britain was highly industrialised and governed by right wing parties either the Whigs or the...

The Function of the Inspector in the Play An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley

1541 words - 6 pages The Function of the Inspector in the Play An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley The Inspector is the backbone of the play and orchestrates the entire storyline. He is described on his entrance as creating 'an impression of massiveness, solidity and purposefulness.' symbolising the fact that he is an unstoppable force within the play. His 'disconcerting habit of looking hard at the person he addresses before speaking' ...

Analysis of the Inspector in An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley

2038 words - 8 pages Analysis of the Inspector in An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley The word Inspector suggests someone who looks closely at things, and this is his role in the events of the play. This, and the fact that Priestly recognised the Birlings would almost certainly have refused to be questioned by a common policeman, is probably the reason why the person to bring the news of Eva/Daisy's death is portrayed as an ...

An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley

1986 words - 8 pages An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley Title: How does Priestley's play give an audience a dramatic experience in which they are made to think about how people ought to live their lives? Answer with reference to the script and any productions you may have seen or heard about. J.B. Priestley wrote 'An Inspector Calls' in 1945, at the end of the Second World War and set the 20th Century drama in 1912, just before ...

An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley

2751 words - 11 pages An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley In Priestley's play An Inspector Calls, the two main characters, Arthur Birling and the Inspector, both show certain features of real people but, in particular the Inspector seems to be representative of political and social issues that were relevant in 1912. What seems like a simple detective thriller, with an inspector asking questions and the other characters answering them in...

An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley

1625 words - 7 pages An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley Consider how J.B Priestley combines dramatic effectiveness with political comment in 'An Inspector Calls.' An Inspector Calls can be described as a carefully constructed play as the author, J.B Priestley, cleverly combines dramatic effectiveness with strong political comment to create an entertaining play based on morals and ethics to make the audience think about the issues ...

Sheila and Mrs. Birling of J.B. Priestley's An Inspector Calls

  • Length: 803 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - More ↓
Sheila and Mrs. Birling of J.B. Priestley's An Inspector Calls

In my opinion, the two characters with the most contradictory ideas,
attitudes and responses throughout the whole novel are Mrs.Birling and
Sheila, Mrs.Birling daughter.

At the beginning of the play the first descriptions of Sheila and
Mrs.Birling are different. They have different opinions on importance
and life. After the Inspector arrives both women react in a different
way to the news; one is distressed and the other unfazed. They seem
to be on diverging terms with each other. Mainly in the way each
confess their connections with Eva Smith and the way they behave after
the Inspector leaves. At the beginning of Act 1, Sheila is a very
different person from the character at the end of Act 3. She has just
got engaged to Gerald Croft, and is very excited about her future. She
can only think of herself, and has no other worries. As the play
begins the home is described as heavily comfortable but not cosy and
homelike. This reflects the mother, Mrs.Birling, who is a rather cold
woman and her husband's social superior, whereas Sheila is a pretty
girl who is rather pleased with her life. For example, when the
Inspector arrives, Mrs.Birling grandly says to him, “My husband was
Lord Mayor”. Sheila does not follow her mother's ways because she
decides to give back her engagement ring to Gerald. Even when he
tries to give it back she refuses. Gerald is Sheila's social superior
but she seems to be a person who would only marry for love and not for
money or status. On the other hand I think that Mrs.Birling would
marry for power and money.

Sheila’s whole outlook on life is very positive. Everything is perfect
for her, and she has never suffered lack of money. She is somewhat
spoiled and expects everything to go right for her.

Another example of contradiction is the change in language. Throughout
the play Mrs.Birling language does not change at all she continually

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Sheila and Mrs. Birling of J.B. Priestley's An Inspector Calls." 123HelpMe.com. 13 Mar 2018
    <http://www.123HelpMe.com/view.asp?id=142428>.

LengthColor Rating 
Arthur Birling and Sheila Birling in An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley - Arthur Birling and Sheila Birling in An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley I have chosen to write my essay about Mr.Arthur Birling and Mrs. Sheila Birling. I have chosen these characters because they have different views on the events concerning Eva Smith. Sheila, for instance, felt extremely regretful about the incident involving the sacking of Eva Smith and we can tell this because she says 'And I'm desperately sorry' neither did she show any relief after hearing that the inspector was a hoax....   [tags: Papers]735 words
(2.1 pages)
Good Essays[preview]
Difference in Reactions of Sheila Birling and Her Father in J.B. Priestley's An Inspector Calls - Difference in Reactions of Sheila Birling and Her Father in J.B. Priestley's An Inspector Calls Coursework. Sheila Birling and her father react totally differently to the 'inspector.' How far would the audience agree. Author Birling I do agree that Sheila Birling and her father Author Birling react differently to the inspector. This shows because when the inspector was talking to Author Birling, he was very annoyed at the inspector and didn't want to listen to what he had to say, this shows when Author says to the inspector "Look here inspector, im half a mind to report you....   [tags: Papers]1043 words
(3 pages)
Good Essays[preview]
Comparison of The Attitudes Of Arthur Birling And Sheila Birling From An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley - Comparison of The Attitudes Of Arthur Birling And Sheila Birling From An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley An Inspector Calls by J.B Priestley was first performed in 1945. The play was set in 1912 before the war; it centres on the wealthy Birling family. A visit from the mysterious Inspector Goole, during the celebration of Sheila Birling's and Gerald Croft's engagement, proves to be a horrifying experience for them as they learn that they have all played a part in the suicide of a young girl called Eva Smith....   [tags: Papers]912 words
(2.6 pages)
Good Essays[preview]
J.B Priestley use of Sheila Birling to Convey His Message to the Audience in An Inspector Calls - J.B Priestley use of Sheila Birling to Convey His Message to the Audience in An Inspector Calls In An Inspector Calls, Sheila Birling is an important character, used by J.B Priestley to put across his message to the audience. I am going to talk about socio-historic content, Sheila at the beginning of the play, Sheila’s reaction to; finding out the girl had died; finding out her father sacked the girl; finding out she contributed to the girl getting fired; finding out that Gerald knew the girl and finding out that her mother refused to help the girl....   [tags: Papers]1095 words
(3.1 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
Essay about Sheila in Priestley's An Inspector Calls - Sheila in Priestley's An Inspector Calls Sheila Birling was created by Priestly to convey his socialist political views about the way Britain and society ran. Two years before the First World War 1912 was a time when the country was split by class divisions. People with wealth had power over the lower classes in the social hierarchy....   [tags: Papers]1148 words
(3.3 pages)
Good Essays[preview]
Change in Sheila's Character throughout An Inspector Calls Essays - Change in Sheila's Character throughout An Inspector Calls J B Priestly ‘s ‘An Inspector Calls’ is set in 1912 and was first performed in 1945. This mean there is Dramatic Irony over Birling ‘s comment about war. The plot concerns Eva Smith a working class girl who commits sucide. She used to work in Birling ‘s factory and every family member affected her life. An inspector comes to their house for investigation. Priestly message to the audience is that everyone in society is responsible for their own actions and the way in which they affect others....   [tags: An Inspector Calls J.B. Priestley Sheila Essays]592 words
(1.7 pages)
Good Essays[preview]
Sheila in J.B. Priestley's An Inspector Calls’ Essay - Sheila in J.B. Priestley's An Inspector Calls’ Sheila, is one of the more sympathetic characters in contrast to the other members of the Birling family she also has the most conscience compared to any of the characters in the book. Sheila is the daughter of Arthur Birling one of the most wealthiest business of the area (Brumly). Sheila is a relatively observant and perceptive character who seems to be the first to notice that the inspector is no ordinary police man on official duty....   [tags: Papers]862 words
(2.5 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley Essay - An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley An Inspector Calls, by J.B. Priestly, is the story of the visit by an Inspector to an apparently normal family, the Birlings. They are celebrating Sheila Birling's engagement to Gerald Croft, who is also present, when the Inspector arrives telling them of the suicide of a young girl called Eva Smith. At first they deny any knowledge of the girl, but as the play goes on the Inspector manages to show that they all helped kill her. Mr Birling had her dismissed from his factory for demanding a small increase in wages; Sheila ordered her to be dismissed from her job in a shop simply because of her pride; Gerald Croft kept her as his mistress before leaving h...   [tags: Inspector Calls Priestley Essays]5227 words
(14.9 pages)
Powerful Essays[preview]
Essay on An Inspector Calls by J.B. Priestley - "An Inspector Calls" by J.B. Priestley The play ‘An Inspector Calls’ was written in 1945, which was just at the end of the Second World War. The play is set in 1912, just before the First World War. The play was set at this particular time so that J.B. Priestley could get his message across more clearly. The message was that we all have to take responsibility for our actions, which can have consequences. Another reason why this may be a ‘well made’ play is that J.B. Priestley gives hints to the audience at the beginning, which builds up excitement and interest....   [tags: Inspector Calls J.B. Priestley Essays]1974 words
(5.6 pages)
Powerful Essays[preview]
J.B. Priestley's Play "An Inspector Calls" Essay - J.B. Priestley's Play "An Inspector Calls" "Why shouldn't they try for higher wages. We try for the highest possible prices. And I don't see why she should have been sacked". Eric to Mr Birling says this. Eric is drawing a comparison between the Upper class owners, and the lower class workers. Eric can see the comparison between Mr Birling trying to do the best for him, and the workers doing the same for themselves and their families. Mr Birling won't allow these sentiments, however, and sees them as a bad attitude....   [tags: Priestley Inspector Calls Essays]851 words
(2.4 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]



uses the words “rude” and “impertinent.” However Sheila's language
changes from scurfy, to a more serious tone towards the end of the
play which, echoes the Inspector's tone. For example she says, after
the Inspector has left, “Mother hardened her heart.”

After the Inspector arrives and delivers the horrific news of Eva
Smith's death both women react differently to it. When Sheila enters
the room after the inspector has arrived, she doesn’t know he is
there. She acts surprised to see him, and says“Oh- sorry. I didn’t
know.” She asks what the Inspector is doing there, saying,

“What’s all this about?” She does not expect it to be anything either
very unpleasant, or anything involving her. When her father says,
“Nothing to do with you, Sheila. Run along.” it shows that he is
trying to protect her from having anything to do with the situation.
Again, it seems that Sheila is overprotected from unpleasant things
like this, and always has been. Sheila's first reaction is “Oh how
horrible!” and later she asks questions such as “What happened to her
then?” This shows her distress and real concern for Eva. Later, she
talks “warmly” about what she thinks about Eva's death which is a
“rotten shame.” This shows that she is honest when she says this.
Sheila also says, “These girls aren't cheap labour - they're people.”
This shows that Sheila is broad-minded and can see the problems with
society. All these reactions contrast Mrs. Birling's. When
Mrs.Birling is questioned on her conduct in regard to not giving Eva
Smith any charitable money, she is still unsympathetic towards her,
saying “she only had herself to blame” and when she says “Girls of
that class”, she stereotypes Eva Smith as being poor and therefore
unhappy and that is the real reason for her committing suicide. Sheila
can see the problems with society whereas her mother either doesn’t
know or turns a blind eye to the problems.

Again, Sheila and Mrs.Birling respond differently when they find out
that they have a connection with Eva's death. We can see that Sheila
has become more mature in her attitudes. She has admitted her part in
the death of Eva Smith. Sheila is clearly very sorry for what she did
to Eva Smith, which is obvious when she says,

“I behaved badly too. I know I did. I’m ashamed of it.” She has
learned, from the Inspector’s visit, to be less self-centred. She is
more sensitive towards other people. She is taking responsibility for
Eva Smith’s death and is upset at her parents because they are trying
to pretend nothing ever happened. She is on the verge of breaking down
and she does not make any excuses on her behalf. She tells the
complete truth and even if she told lies no one could contradict her.
On the other hand, Mrs. Birling is trying to avoid getting caught. She
says “I shall be glad to answer any questions the Inspector wishes to
ask me” and she is probably thinking that she can never get caught.
However this changes when the Inspector questions her. She then says,
“I don't think we need to discuss it.” I think this shows that she
knows she is guilty and she does not want to make herself more at
fault than she already is. She does not accept her responsibilities
because she tries to alter the blame on to other people. Finally, she
says “I accept no blame for it al all”, which indicates that she
doesn’t feel any sympathy at all for Eva Smith.

Throughout the whole play I see no resemblance between Sheila and Mrs.
Birling. During the Inspector’s visit, Sheila changed from a selfish,
spoiled, excited, newly engaged girl, into a caring, responsible and
open-minded person. Out of all the Birlings, and Gerald Croft, Sheila
changes the most. She learns from the Inspector, and understands the
purpose of his visit; to warn them of what will happen if they do not
change their ways. She admits her wrong actions, regrets and learns
from her mistakes and therefore she can become a better person in the
future. On the contrary, her mother, who is supposed to be an adult
does not admit her obvious and unashamed guilt and therefore learns
nothing.



Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *